One of my greatest childhood regrets was that I was not Egyptian. I corrected this by calling myself Isis in secret. Osiris was my imaginary boyfriend. Yes, really. When we had to name GBM, we made a long list for girls and a very short one for boys (I just knew it in my bones that it wasn't a fella in there!). After she was born, we finally picked a name that wasn't there in either of the two lists. Both M and I agreed that the name suited her, had a good meaning, sounded nice phonetically blah blah. My secret reason for agreeing on the name, however, was that it ends with a 'ra'. I'm hoping GBM will have an Egyptian phase like I did and insist on everyone calling her Ra. Heh.
Which of course, makes me one of those dunderhead parents who actually believes their children will care about fulfilling their hopes. If my own track record is anything to go by, this is a highly foolish dream. My mum desperately wanted me to be all classical. Like learn Bharatanatyam and Carnatic music. I did learn Bharatanatyam. For two torturous weeks. After which, I gave up because the class timings clashed with Oliyum Olliyum on Doordarshan.Now, I'm playing all sorts of classical songs for GBM (phoney, phoney me). Last week, I also introduced her to the Beatles. So that, you know, when she becomes a depressed teenager, she can be depressed with class.
My mum also tried to get me to learn to read and write Malayalam. I was least interested in this project as well. Currently, however, I'm feverishly reciting Malayalam nursery rhymes to GBM. Similarly, M, who never admits to his Telugu identity and insists on calling himself a Tamilian, only speaks to GBM in Telugu. So much so that I find myself speaking to her in Telugu-mixed-Malayalam at times.
I wonder what GBM will eventually speak. M and I mostly speak to each other in English. I can understand Telugu (or at least, the Chennai-Telugu that M speaks) but cannot speak it. M can understand Malayalam and speak it like Vivek in Tamil movies. The only regional language we both can read, write, and speak is Tamil. We live in Maharashtra where most people speak Marathi as their first choice and Hindi only if we request them to (it's only recently that I discovered that Marathi and Hindi are actually very different languages- I always assumed they were more or less the same since I couldn't understand either). I really don't know how this child is going to speak though we will, of course, harass her in the first few years of her life by acting patriotic and insisting on her learning three Dravidian languages all at once. She'll probably end up speaking a bit of each and learn none of the languages properly.
Deep down, I think I don't care. I don't think I'd mind very much if she only learned English properly. There, I said it. Not because I think English is superior to the other languages but because it makes sense practically speaking. That's one language she's got to learn properly if she's to survive her education (and her grammar Nazi mother). Neither M nor I bothered to learn our respective mother tongues (just like several other parents), so why should we push it down GBM's throat? She'll obviously have to learn the local language if she's to get by (which I still haven't but manage to get by because I work out of my bed). But really, if she doesn't want to learn everything else, I don't think I'm going to push her and get all holy-cow. I know this is how languages die and we-must-take-pride-in-our-culture yada yada, but really, decimal numbers are bad enough to contend with as a kid. Why make life more difficult?
I'm going to try and find out if she's interested in learning dance/music/skating/tennis/swimming/salsa/maggi noodles and so on like a dutiful mother, but if she doesn't give a damn, I'm going to be happy. I mean, I was happy being a useless lump as a kid, so why not? I don't think I'll be heartbroken if she doesn't become Airtel Super Singer or receive commendation from Kala Master.
I hope GBM will read though :| I've already put together a picture book collection for her and all. I think I'll find it hard to accept if she's not much of a reader. Or turns into one of those bimbettey girls who is forever trying on lipstick (there's no lipstick at home though...she could try and look Goth with my kajal if she wants). I'd feel a little let down by these two factors considering I'm a children's writer who did General Studies and everything. But ah well, as a parent,the sooner I accept my inability to influence my child, the longer I'll keep my marbles.
I will, however, bring her up to believe that Egyptians are cool.
Which of course, makes me one of those dunderhead parents who actually believes their children will care about fulfilling their hopes. If my own track record is anything to go by, this is a highly foolish dream. My mum desperately wanted me to be all classical. Like learn Bharatanatyam and Carnatic music. I did learn Bharatanatyam. For two torturous weeks. After which, I gave up because the class timings clashed with Oliyum Olliyum on Doordarshan.Now, I'm playing all sorts of classical songs for GBM (phoney, phoney me). Last week, I also introduced her to the Beatles. So that, you know, when she becomes a depressed teenager, she can be depressed with class.
My mum also tried to get me to learn to read and write Malayalam. I was least interested in this project as well. Currently, however, I'm feverishly reciting Malayalam nursery rhymes to GBM. Similarly, M, who never admits to his Telugu identity and insists on calling himself a Tamilian, only speaks to GBM in Telugu. So much so that I find myself speaking to her in Telugu-mixed-Malayalam at times.
I wonder what GBM will eventually speak. M and I mostly speak to each other in English. I can understand Telugu (or at least, the Chennai-Telugu that M speaks) but cannot speak it. M can understand Malayalam and speak it like Vivek in Tamil movies. The only regional language we both can read, write, and speak is Tamil. We live in Maharashtra where most people speak Marathi as their first choice and Hindi only if we request them to (it's only recently that I discovered that Marathi and Hindi are actually very different languages- I always assumed they were more or less the same since I couldn't understand either). I really don't know how this child is going to speak though we will, of course, harass her in the first few years of her life by acting patriotic and insisting on her learning three Dravidian languages all at once. She'll probably end up speaking a bit of each and learn none of the languages properly.
Deep down, I think I don't care. I don't think I'd mind very much if she only learned English properly. There, I said it. Not because I think English is superior to the other languages but because it makes sense practically speaking. That's one language she's got to learn properly if she's to survive her education (and her grammar Nazi mother). Neither M nor I bothered to learn our respective mother tongues (just like several other parents), so why should we push it down GBM's throat? She'll obviously have to learn the local language if she's to get by (which I still haven't but manage to get by because I work out of my bed). But really, if she doesn't want to learn everything else, I don't think I'm going to push her and get all holy-cow. I know this is how languages die and we-must-take-pride-in-our-culture yada yada, but really, decimal numbers are bad enough to contend with as a kid. Why make life more difficult?
I'm going to try and find out if she's interested in learning dance/music/skating/tennis/swimming/salsa/maggi noodles and so on like a dutiful mother, but if she doesn't give a damn, I'm going to be happy. I mean, I was happy being a useless lump as a kid, so why not? I don't think I'll be heartbroken if she doesn't become Airtel Super Singer or receive commendation from Kala Master.
I hope GBM will read though :| I've already put together a picture book collection for her and all. I think I'll find it hard to accept if she's not much of a reader. Or turns into one of those bimbettey girls who is forever trying on lipstick (there's no lipstick at home though...she could try and look Goth with my kajal if she wants). I'd feel a little let down by these two factors considering I'm a children's writer who did General Studies and everything. But ah well, as a parent,the sooner I accept my inability to influence my child, the longer I'll keep my marbles.
I will, however, bring her up to believe that Egyptians are cool.


17 comments:
hahahaha! the language problem starts eh? R speaks only Hindi...Mumbaiyya Hindi coupled with Gujju (from mother) Tamizh (From father) English (From teacher) Bong (from father) well...i think she will be a linguist...one can always hope na!
Ra - seriously GB...you think GBM would respond to Ra *rolls eyes*
Hugs to the little one and do introduce her to everything...after all we can only do that much na :)
Apt title for the post.. Lot of our kids are Kichdis but tasty ones!Somehow wants our kids to appreciate our background but cannot drill it into them. They will have their own way.
And Ra? reminds me of Ra one:). You definitely dont want her to be reminded of this association.
One added dimension is religious songs our kids will be exposed to rather than hear to only Mangaatha and Maariatha.
My name ends with a 'ra' and I always thought I was one-eighth Egyptian :D
LOL...you're kid is just months old!
You're blog is turning into a mommy blog GB!
Ha ha ha. Enjoying the plight you're going through - she's gonna speak like Marathi Manoos and do the Maharashtrians proud. :)
You are marvellously evolving as a mommy blogger! Ra, will find out her language. She will learn and then forget one and then learn another, or she will learn several thoda -thoda..Don't you worry. But Egypt is cool I agree! Now lets see if Ra agrees too! May be she will find Venezuela or Peurto Rico more glamourous instead!
I am loving the common parental concerns your are going through and the uncommon way you are putting them..Keep going dear
Just a minute ago I read this quote from The Prophet on a FB comment and then I see your post!
Reproducing the quote below:
Your children are not your children.
They are the sons and daughters of Life's longing for itself.
They come through you but not from you,
And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.
You may give them your love but not your thoughts,
For they have their own thoughts.
You may house their bodies but not their souls,
For their souls dwell in the house of tomorrow, which you cannot visit, not even in your dreams.
You may strive to be like them, but seek not to make them like you.
For life goes not backward nor tarries with yesterday.
You are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth.
-V
I stumbled upon your blog recently and girl, have I been loving it! Just love your whacky sense of humour. Have finished reading through most of your posts and like some ‘Venkatasubramani ‘, have been making mental notes about what GB did and is doing now.
Only the other day, I was wondering what language would GBM learn eventually and was hoping to read a blog on that from you. So, when I saw this post, it brought a big smile on my face-there! GB has already blogged about this.
Waiting to get some of your published books and read them. Much love to GBM.
I don't want to spoil that joyous post with a serious comment, but I feel rather obliged to show off as a linguist. :D
I think GBM will learn to speak Marathi (probably Hindi) and English excellently, if you and M are going to stay in Maharashtra for any length of time during her childhood. Tamil, Telugu and Malayalam may be tricky and depends solely on how much of these languages she frequently has at her earshot.
"Last week, I also introduced her to the Beatles. So that, you know, when she becomes a depressed teenager, she can be depressed with class." - :D. read that line over and over again!
One National integration only young Ra is. :)
'So that, you know, when she becomes a depressed teenager, she can be depressed with class.' LMAO
HAHAHAHAHAHA I am still laughing :D ( I actually choked coz I laughed so much :P )
My mom tried joining me in music classes but all my teachers died or got transferred lol
and eyptians are cool indeed x)
@R's Mom- Heyyyy, Ra is kewl. She should be grateful to me!
@Sam- We're not very religious but I guess a lot of Carnatic stuff is religious anyway! I'm sure she'll ask me to stuff it when she learns to speak!
@Suchitra- You're so lucky, you know that, right?
@Gymnast- Right now, mommyhood is my profession...what do ya expect?
@Anon- Yeah, that IS going to be hilarious considering my Hindi and Marathi expertise.
@Chandrima- I'm sure I'll start baking next ;)
@V- Yup, have read that before. And I agree. Which is why, I admit I'm never going to be able to influence her.
@Nithvin- Why wait to get my books? Go and Flipkart now itself :D And thank you...hehe.
@Srini- The kids in the colony are all kichidis mostly, so I'm not sure if she'll learn Marathi...not till she starts school anyway. And thanks :D
@Vishesh- I'll drink orange juice to that!
@Semi- You are too cheerful for a teenager :P
.well,like all kichidi kids GBM will defenitely learn at least two languages apart from English. Even the 'pure' ones do that in all Indian cities.And your 'fears' about she not picking up reading habits is not serious, you do feel it'in your bones'.
As for introducing her to all other activities,just be practial--do not let what you can not do interfere with what you can do.After all the art of parenting lies in a fine mingling of letting go and holding on.It is like playing veena in public and learning the instrument as one goes on.It will be worth it though.
Carnatic music is all about celebration of life;religion is just a samll part of it---our great epics in enchanting ragas.Not enjoying them does not sound like a right regret.
As the quality of life is detrmined by its activities learning how to learn will be the most important skill Ra needs to acquire.Help her when she needs it, keep off the grass,well you should know when!
Hi GB,Loved your blog, but worried secretly that it will turn into a mummy blog... and after reading this post , i am thinking it already has... understand you are a new mum. but pls don't become yet another young indian mother obsessed with her kid. there are hundreds around. and when they do not stop talking about their offspring- best one can do is ignore both.
@Amma- Okayji. I will carve out the words on a golden plaque as usual :D
@Anonymous- I'm sorry if my posts bore you, but I write about what's happening with my life here and since nothing much is happening right now other than me being a mother, there's precious little I can write about otherwise. You are welcome to come back when I do start writing about other things....whenever that happens!
Check with your forklift manufacturer (Toyota Material Handling USA, Clark, Yale, Hyster, Crown, Big Joe, etc) to make sure that using forklift extensions will not void warranty on your machine. Yale Forklift Repair Download Used Mitsubishi Forklift For Sale In Rochester When charging forklift batteries you need to take into account the following facts for the sake of safety:
Brokersring.com - Learn how to turn $500 into $5,000 in a month!
[url=http://www.brokersring.com/]Make Money Online[/url] - The Secret Reveled with Binary Option
Binary Options is the way to [url=http://www.brokersring.com/]make money[/url] securely online
Post a Comment